News

Kalshi loses Maryland injunction appeal in Fourth Circuit

The divided panel reached the same outcome through different legal arguments as appellate courts continue to split over sports event contracts.

· 2 min read
Share this article
Follow us on Google
AI Summary
Sign in to listen
kalshi-circuit
Key Points
Fourth Circuit affirms the denial of Kalshi's request to block Maryland gambling enforcement during its lawsuit
Two judges agreed on the result but differed on whether federal commodities law covers the contracts
The ruling leaves the underlying case pending amid conflicting decisions in other federal circuits

Kalshi has lost its appeal seeking to stop Maryland from applying state gambling laws to its sports event contracts while a federal lawsuit continues.

The US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit affirmed the denial of a preliminary injunction on November 17 in a 2-1 decision. 

The judgment does not resolve the underlying case or establish a single majority position on whether Kalshi's contracts qualify as swaps under federal commodities law.

Maryland's lottery and gaming regulator sent Kalshi a cease and desist letter in April 2025, alleging that the exchange was offering sports wagering to residents without a state license. 

Kalshi sued later that month, arguing that its status as a federally regulated derivatives exchange placed its contracts under the exclusive authority of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). 

A Maryland district court declined to give Kalshi preliminary protection from enforcement in August 2025.

In a concurring opinion, Judge Roger Gregory said he did not need to decide whether the sports contracts were swaps. Even if they were, he found that Kalshi had not shown that federal law clearly displaced Maryland's authority over gambling or made compliance with both regimes impossible.

Judge Stephanie Thacker also voted to affirm, but concluded that sports event contracts are not swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act. On that reading, the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction over exchange-traded swaps would not apply. 

Judge DeAndrea Benjamin dissented. She considered the contracts swaps and would have sent the case back for the district court to assess the remaining requirements for an injunction.

The disagreement extends beyond Maryland. The Fourth Circuit opinion cites a Third Circuit ruling favorable to Kalshi in New Jersey and decisions from the Sixth and Ninth Circuits rejecting its federal preemption argument in other states. Those differing outcomes leave the treatment of sports event contracts dependent on the jurisdiction and the stage of each case.

In earlier coverage of the same dispute, Maryland's Attorney General defended the initial denial of Kalshi's injunction before the Fourth Circuit issued its decision.

Good to know

The Fourth Circuit heard oral argument on May 7, more than six months before issuing its opinion

Reaction Board

News Analysis

View All
Campeon Gaming Q&A - sustainable growth

Campeón Gaming Q&A: How to achieve sustainable growth

Sotiris Pappas, Director of Operational Strategy at Campeón Gaming, shares his thoughts on maximising operator profitability.

4 min read • • By Patrick Fasolis
Court Hearing Analysis

US Senators: CFTC ‘anything but a blank slate’ with prediction markets

The US Senate Agriculture Committee was given the chance to question CFTC Commissioner nominees Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland, both having been put forward by President Donald Trump.

5 min read • • By Kirk Geller
ahora que colombia

What next for Coljuegos after Jaime Vives Pinedo departure?

Jaime Vives Pinedo has left Coljuegos less than a month after taking office, following a controversy over his postgraduate degree. How will the regulator's next leadership address questions about transparency and accountability?

5 min read • • By Milagros del Priore

In The News

View All