The US Senate Agriculture Committee held a court hearing on two nominations made by President Donald Trump to serve as Commissioners of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), including Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland.
Both Anonick and Rowland had an opportunity to address the Committee prior to receiving consideration on November 17.
Opening remarks
“The evolution of technology has resulted in new frontier markets that fall under the CFTC’s jurisdiction,” Anonick said.
“In just a short period of time, we have witnessed rapid technological change and adoption that allows people to manage risk in ways that weren’t imaginable just 10 years ago. As technology, businesses, markets and consumer demands evolve, regulation needs to keep pace. This requires flexibility, engagement and clear rules necessary to meet rapidly evolving markets.”
Anonick continued by stating he looks forward to potentially working with CFTC Chairman Michael Selig in ensuring derivatives markets are “appropriately regulated and policed."
Rowland is the first member of the Democratic Party to be nominated for a position with the CFTC by President Trump, perhaps a resulting factor of the recent “Blue Wave” which hit the US after the 2026 Midterm Elections.
Speaking on his nomination, Rowland said: “The US derivatives markets are the strongest and the most liquid in the world. They enable market participants to manage risk and discover prices. Overseeing the safe functions of these markets and protecting them from fraud, manipulation and other abuse is a core mission of the CFTC.
“Our flexible regulatory framework accomplishes this while still enabling responsible innovation. The CFTC works best with a range of views at the table. I’m aware of the significant staff attrition and disruption that took place in 2025, and look forward to working with Chairman Selig and my fellow Commissioners to get back to appropriate staffing levels.”
Rowland was asked whether the increased retail participation in prediction markets was a concern, believing the CFTC should “adapt the rules” which implement its core principles and strengthen consumer protections – specifically in marketing and advertising.
I don't know if I've ever been so blatantly deceived by a nominee before. This is certainly not the kind of leadership we need at CFTC
Rowland also confirmed expectations that a Supreme Court decision will be handed down on event contracts within President Trump’s current term “or the one after,” and that the CFTC will be “bound by the Court’s decision.”
Fire away!
Senator Tina Smith addressed the CFTC’s lawsuit against Minnesota lawmakers, believing prediction markets are “operating in violation” of state regulations. Smith asked if there was any “practical difference” between a sports wager and sports event contract, to which the two nominees appeared less than comfortable to answer.
Rowland stated he is “sympathetic” to state regulators, while Anonick didn’t want to “tip the scales” on prediction markets’ legality in the US. Smith pushed back by stating this “isn’t an emotional issue, this is a legal issue.”
The Senator stated she is “going to count on” Rowland and Anonick to “follow the law” when it comes to state and Federal regulation of prediction markets.
Senator Ben Ray Luján was passionate in questioning whether CFTC enforcement has kept pace with prediction markets, stating he knows both Commissioners “didn’t want to upset” President Trump “or else he’ll pull your nomination.”
Luján appeared greatly concerned over prediction market threats toward Indian gaming, as well as the restricted capabilities of state regulators. The Senator “doesn’t want to be lied to,” and even went as far as to question whether Anonick and Rowland were telling the truth during their testimonies.
As technology, businesses, markets and consumer demands evolve, regulation needs to keep pace. This requires flexibility, engagement and clear rules necessary to meet rapidly evolving markets
Senator Adam Schiff took his turn to fire questions at the two nominees, believing Chairman Selig must’ve had an "epiphany" when it comes to sports betting following his own approval process.
“I don’t know whether he was just lying to us or once he was confirmed he had some kind of an epiphany, but he has been anything but a blank slate,” Schiff said.
“He has not looked to the courts, he has filed briefs to tell the courts what to do. And when the courts have ruled in a way that doesn't favor the prediction markets, he has basically told companies to ignore the courts. ‘Don’t geofence, don’t respect state or Tribal laws.’
“I don’t know if I’ve ever been so blatantly deceived by a nominee before. This is certainly not the kind of leadership we need at CFTC.”
Schiff then asked both Anonick and Rowland whether a sports event contract acts similarly to a sports bet, to which Anonick described the question as “legally complex.”
“Is it really complex?” Schiff countered, “If we’re betting on who is going to win a football game on Thursday night, it kinda sounds like a sports bet, right?”
Anonick stressed he will keep an open mind to prediction market regulation, to which Schiff stated he hopes he won’t be reading Anonick’s testimony back in similar fashion to Chairman Selig.
Quantity over quality?
The CFTC consists of a five-member committee who regulate the US derivatives markets, including futures and swaps, with rulemaking, enforcement actions and significant policy statements typically pushed forward by a majority vote.
The CFTC works best with a range of views at the table. I'm aware of the significant staff attrition and disruption that took place in 2025, and look forward to working with Chairman Selig and my fellow Commissioners to get back to appropriate staffing levels
Pending the approval of Anonick and Rowland, Selig is the only Senate-approved Commissioner currently serving the CFTC.
While Anonick and Rowland were hesitant to take sides in the Federal vs state battle surrounding prediction markets, the concern shown over whether the CFTC is properly staffed could be the deciding factor in their potential approval.
On numerous occasions, Senators who took part in the hearing questioned if the CFTC requires additional Commissioners to properly regulate prediction and derivatives markets, to which both nominees happily confirmed.
Given the dual-sided political standing of Anonick and Rowland, pushing forward both their nominations should offer a rare sense of equality for the US Senate Agriculture Committee.
The record for both nominations will remain open for 48 hours, although the Committee did confirm it will attempt to offer a decision on both nominations as soon as they are able.
Underdog Fantasy introduced drive-by-drive prediction markets for the NFL on November 12, even as the CFTC continues to crack down on the trading type due to potential manipulation