The Paraná State Lottery (Lottopar) will be allowed to keep its contract to operate the instant games (scratch-offs) until June 6, 2034. This confirmation comes regardless of the irregularities that have been discovered by the Paraná State Court of Auditors (TCE-PR).
The decision followed an extraordinary audit examining the procedure behind Concession Contract No. 005/2024.
As per the TCE-PR, the procurement process had flaws in its planning, commercial model and regulatory framework.
The principal irregularity was the use of accreditation to determine which company would operate the instant lottery.
Accreditation is an administrative procedure through which public authorities qualify interested parties that meet specified requirements. However, the court determined that this mechanism was unsuitable for delegating a public service to a private operator.
Instead, the concession should have been awarded through a competitive bidding process involving interested companies and specific selection criteria.
Under the ruling, Lottopar is now banned from using accreditation again to delegate this type of service. Any future concession will have to be awarded via competitive tender to ensure there is wider participation.
Although the court upheld its findings regarding irregularities in the concession process, it ruled against imposing sanctions or requiring the repayment of funds.
According to the court's assessment, the case did not establish intent or gross negligence. It also found no actual and quantifiable damage to public funds.
Lottopar will also be required to strengthen its monitoring and consumer protection measures, including oversight of revenue collection, allocation of funds and compliance with the concessionaire's contractual obligations. The ruling also requires measures to prevent minors from accessing the games.
The Brazilian Football Confederation (CBF) expects the country’s football sector to lose more than BR2bn ($344m) in revenue if betting companies remain prohibited from operating