A bipartisan coalition of 44 US Attorney Generals – co-led by New Jersey AG Jennifer Davenport – have spoken out against proposed rule changes from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to expand the definition of a “swap.”
In October, the CFTC issued an Interim Final Rule, declaring casino-style gambling products such as poker, blackjack and roulette are "excluded" from the definition of a swap.
Along with such revisions, however, the agency also began seeking public comment on expanding the term “swap” to include contracts tied to sports, politics, culture and weather.
“The CFTC continues to stray far outside of its lane by seeking to exclusively regulate certain forms of sports gambling on prediction markets,” Davenport said.
“These actions seek to override states’ longstanding authority to regulate gambling within our borders, which would allow prediction markets to operate without complying with state gambling regulations and safeguards to ensure responsible gaming.”
Previously, Davenport filed an inaugural petition with the US Supreme Court to determine whether prediction markets can legally offer sports-related event contract trading without following state gaming regulations.
In April, a Third Circuit Court in Philadelphia ruled in favor of Kalshi by declaring the CFTC maintained exclusive jurisdiction over sports event contracts and preempted New Jersey’s gaming laws.
Since the decision was handed down, though, a Ninth Circuit Court in San Francisco voted unanimously to forbid Kalshi from filing enforcement action against Nevada regulators, having determined that the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) is unlikely to preempt regulations enforced by the Nevada Gaming Commission.
On November 19, Nevada Representative Dina Titus also sent a letter to the CFTC regarding the agency’s rule change proposal.
“I urge the CFTC to reject its interpretation of ‘swap’ that encompasses sports-related event contracts. Such an approach would effectively transform the CFTC into a Federal gaming regulator, exceed the bounds of the Commission’s intended role, undermine Congress and intrude upon the longstanding authority of states and Tribal governments to regulate gaming within their jurisdictions,” Titus said.
“Regardless of how these products are labeled, sports-event contracts are functionally indistinguishable from traditional sports wagering. For decades, states have policed sports betting. Nothing in the CEA suggests Congress intended to transfer that authority to the Commission simply because a wager is packaged as a financial contract.
“The Commission’s proposed rule appears to be a last-ditch effort to accomplish through agency rulemaking what it has thus far been unable to establish in court. Rather than accept the limits of its statutory authority as recognized by the courts, the Commission now appears intent on rewriting the rules of the game to secure the jurisdiction it has been unable to defend through litigation.”
The only US Attorney Generals not to join Davenport’s coalition were from Florida, Georgia, Missouri, Montana, New Hampshire, North Dakota, Texas, Washington, West Virginia and Wyoming.
On November 17, nine US Senators issued CFTC Chairman Michael Selig a letter demanding the agency implement geofencing measures to limit certain event contracts based on location