News

Dutch Supreme Court backs operators in gambling loss cases

The Dutch Supreme Court has found no legal basis for gamblers to recover losses from online gambling activity before market liberalisation in October 2021.

· 1 min read
Share this article
Follow us on Google
AI Summary
Sign in to listen
Netherlands Supreme Court Reimbursment
Key Points
The reasoning follows the Advocate General’s advice and differs from outcomes in jurisdictions such as Germany and Austria, where courts have more often supported player claims
The judgment sits within a broader EU legal context, including a European Court of Justice ruling in case C-440/23 involving Lottoland, which upheld Germany’s pre-2021 online casino ban as compatible with EU law

The Dutch Supreme Court has answered preliminary questions concerning online gambling activity before market liberalisation in October 2021, concluding that gamblers cannot reclaim losses on the basis that agreements were void. The court followed the Advocate General’s advice in full.

The case stemmed from legal proceedings brought by Dutch players who argued that losses incurred on offshore gambling sites before market regulation took effect should be recoverable because the underlying contracts were invalid. The courts in North Holland and Amsterdam referred the matter to the Supreme Court for clarification.

In its reasoning, the Supreme Court found no basis to declare such agreements invalid. Various Dutch legal experts representing players in these cases have argued that claims could potentially be based on alternative legal grounds. The Court’s position leaves opportunities for this, and lawyers will seek different avenues.

The reasoning of the Dutch Supreme Court differs from that of courts in other European countries, such as Germany and Austria, which have generally supported players.

It also follows the European Court of Justice ruling in case C-440/23, in which a German player brought a claim against Malta-based secondary lottery operator Lottoland seeking to recover gambling losses.

The ECJ confirmed that Germany’s pre-2021 online casino ban was compatible with EU law and that players may reclaim losses without such claims constituting an abuse of rights.

Legal experts suggested that the ECJ ruling may weaken operators’ reliance on EU free movement arguments and could expose them to significant liability claims from European players. However, that may not necessarily hold true in the Netherlands.

Good to know

A May ruling from the ECJ upheld a motion to refund player losses accrued from the Mr Green online casino

Reaction Board

News Analysis

View All
Z Gaming Editorial Sept

Z-Gaming: Retention, technology and the changing iGaming landscape

Global Gaming Insider speaks to the Z-Gaming team about player retention, platform flexibility and the technology shaping long-term iGaming growth.

4 min read • • By Marieta Lezaic
Campeon Gaming Q&A - sustainable growth

Campeón Gaming Q&A: How to achieve sustainable growth

Sotiris Pappas, Director of Operational Strategy at Campeón Gaming, shares his thoughts on maximising operator profitability.

4 min read • • By Patrick Fasolis
Court Hearing Analysis

US Senators: CFTC ‘anything but a blank slate’ with prediction markets

The US Senate Agriculture Committee was given the chance to question CFTC Commissioner nominees Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland, both having been put forward by President Donald Trump.

5 min read • • By Kirk Geller

In The News

View All