News

Governor candidate's casino dream for Manaus runs into a small problem: Federal law

Gubernatorial candidate Maria do Carmo wants to turn Manaus's Tropical Hotel into a casino, but even a win at the polls wouldn't give her the authority to make that happen.

· 1 min read
Share this article
Follow us on Google
AI Summary
Sign in to listen
building
Key Points
Maria do Carmo has proposed converting the Tropical Hotel Manaus into a casino, a plan that depends on federal legislation she will no power over even in a victory
Casino gambling has been banned nationally since a 1946 decree and only the Congress can change that
Bill 2,234/2022, which would legalize casinos, has cleared committee in the Senate but remains pending a full floor vote

Gubernatorial candidate Maria do Carmo has declared she plans turning Manaus' Tropical Hotel into a casino.

Still, the proposal runs into a basic constitutional problem: a state governor has no authority to legalize an activity banned under federal law. 

Casino legalization would require Congress to change national legislation, meaning even a win wouldn't give Do Carmo the power to install roulette tables at the hotel. 

The legal obstacle dates to 1946, when Decree-Law 9,215 reinstated a nationwide ban on gambling under Brazil's Criminal Misdemeanors Law and voided any licenses inconsistent with it. 

Under article 22 of Brazil's Constitution, only the Federal Government can legislate on criminal law and matters involving lotteries and games of chance, meaning Amazonas state cannot unilaterally override the federal ban.

A bill to legalize casinos, Project 2,234/2022, has passed the Chamber of Deputies and received a favorable opinion from the Senate's Constitution and Justice Committee, but remained pending a full floor vote. 

Committee approval doesn't mean casinos are cleared: the legislative process would still need to conclude, potentially returning to the Chamber if amended, before presidential sanction or veto. 

Even if the law changes, the Tropical Hotel wouldn't automatically gain the right to operate gaming; it would need to meet whatever requirements and authorizations the eventual legislation establishes. Do Carmo claims that the hotel "already had a license for this," a statement that remains unexplained given the current federal ban.

A governor can advocate for legalization, engage with federal lawmakers and support tourism and infrastructure policy but cannot guarantee congressional approval, pre-empt federal authorization or ensure a specific hotel gets chosen for a casino license.

Before the ban, in Manaus, councillor Rodrigo Guedes filed a bill proposing to ban advertising and marketing activities by betting companies across the city.

Good to know

Amazonas's runoff is now between Do Carmo and Senator Omar Aziz, who led the first round with 40.63% of valid votes to Do Carmo's 24.49%

Reaction Board

News Analysis

View All
ad-non-ban

Why the UK Government has drawn a line against a comprehensive ad ban

In response to the House of Lords Liaison Committee's Gambling Harm – Time for Action report, the UK Government has rejected the Committee's call for a fundamental overhaul of gambling advertising policy; citing a fascinating threefold reasoning.

6 min read • • By Will Underwood
Z Gaming Editorial Sept

Z-Gaming: Retention, technology and the changing iGaming landscape

Global Gaming Insider speaks to the Z-Gaming team about player retention, platform flexibility and the technology shaping long-term iGaming growth.

4 min read • • By Marieta Lezaic
Campeon Gaming Q&A - sustainable growth

Campeón Gaming Q&A: How to achieve sustainable growth

Sotiris Pappas, Director of Operational Strategy at Campeón Gaming, shares his thoughts on maximising operator profitability.

4 min read • • By Patrick Fasolis

In The News

View All