News

Ohio, 38 other states and DC urge Supreme Court to hear Kalshi case

The coalition says conflicting appeals court rulings have left uncertainty over whether CFTC-regulated sports event contracts must comply with state gambling laws.

· 2 min read
Share this article
Follow us on Google
AI Summary
Sign in to listen
us-court
Key Points
Ohio, 38 other states and the District of Columbia support New Jersey's Supreme Court petition
The states cite conflicting appeals court decisions on federal and state authority over sports event contracts
The brief warns that federal preemption could undermine state gambling safeguards

Ohio and 38 other states, joined by the District of Columbia, have urged the US Supreme Court to review New Jersey regulators' dispute with prediction market operator Kalshi over sports event contracts.

Their amicus brief, submitted on October 7 in Flaherty v. KalshiEX, supports New Jersey's petition for a writ of certiorari. It asks the justices to decide whether the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) prevents states from enforcing their sports gambling laws against contracts listed on federally regulated exchanges.

The coalition argues that the CEA's definition of a swap does not cover sports wagers on a prediction market. Kalshi has argued that its contracts fall within the Commodity Futures Trading Commission's (CFTC) exclusive jurisdiction, placing them beyond state gambling regulation.

The brief points to conflicting appeals court decisions. In April, the Third Circuit upheld preliminary relief for Kalshi against New Jersey regulators. 

The Ninth Circuit later rejected Kalshi's position in a Nevada dispute, while the Sixth Circuit ruled in September that the CEA does not preempt Ohio and Tennessee gambling laws. 

The courts reached those outcomes through different interpretations of the statute.

Ohio's filing says the disagreement has left states, federal regulators and operators facing inconsistent legal treatment across jurisdictions. It also cites litigation involving the CFTC and several states over whether local sports betting rules can be applied to contracts offered on designated contract markets.

The coalition argues that state gaming frameworks contain safeguards that a finding of federal preemption could undermine. It identifies minimum age requirements, exclusion lists, limits on gambling spending and consumer protections among the measures states use to address gambling harm.

The brief also cites a separate July comment from 44 states arguing that the CEA does not preempt state law. That intervention involved a different coalition from the 39 states backing New Jersey's petition.

New Jersey filed its petition in September after the Third Circuit upheld preliminary relief for Kalshi. The Supreme Court has not agreed to hear the case. Kalshi's response deadline has been extended to November 9. 

In September, the National Council of Legislators from Gaming States urged the Supreme Court to review the same dispute, warning that Kalshi's interpretation could weaken states' control over sports betting and other gambling regulation.

Good to know

The brief lists related cases pending in five more federal appeals courts and the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Reaction Board

News Analysis

View All
ad-non-ban

Why the UK Government has drawn a line against a comprehensive ad ban

In response to the House of Lords Liaison Committee's Gambling Harm – Time for Action report, the UK Government has rejected the Committee's call for a fundamental overhaul of gambling advertising policy; citing a fascinating threefold reasoning.

6 min read • • By Will Underwood
Z Gaming Editorial Sept

Z-Gaming: Retention, technology and the changing iGaming landscape

Global Gaming Insider speaks to the Z-Gaming team about player retention, platform flexibility and the technology shaping long-term iGaming growth.

4 min read • • By Marieta Lezaic
Campeon Gaming Q&A - sustainable growth

Campeón Gaming Q&A: How to achieve sustainable growth

Sotiris Pappas, Director of Operational Strategy at Campeón Gaming, shares his thoughts on maximising operator profitability.

4 min read • • By Patrick Fasolis

In The News

View All