The South African National Treasury held a workshop on the proposed 20% national tax on online gambling, which it may introduce in February next year. Following industry backlash, the Treasury has signalled some willingness to reconsider its economic modelling.
The national levy would apply to GGR or online operators, in addition to the existing provincial gambling taxes. These currently range from 6% to 9% for online betting and 10% to 15% for casino gambling.
Lawmakers are primarily driven by their wish to reduce problem gambling rates and disincentivise the activity. Meanwhile, industry disagrees, noting that higher taxes won't solve this issue.
Tamara Stork of Stork Attorneys, representing the Gauteng Off-Course Bookmakers Association, said National Treasury’s discussion paper does not establish a clear link between implementing a tax and a measurable reduction in problematic gambling.
Bookmakers and online gambling operators are worried that tax increases could lead to job losses, players moving to unlicensed alternatives and eventually no additional revenue for the state.
Sun International CEO Ulrik Bengtsson warned that the proposed 20% online tax could significantly affect the group’s business, reducing SunBet’s online operations’ profitability by around 70%. He added that SunBet forms a core part of the group's business model, which employs approximately 7,000 people.
Several legal experts pointed to a Dutch case where an online tax increase delivered only a fraction of the expected revenue gains. At the same time, GGR channelisation dropped to 53%, according to the KSA.
National Treasury Deputy Director-General for Tax Policy Christopher Axelson acknowledged industry concerns and said Treasury will give greater weight to its economic modelling.
However, this does not mean Treasury is backing away from the proposal, with Axelson stressing: “We do think there is a case to intervene… It is about how we do it, what the rate is and what is reasonable.”
The South African Bookmakers Association estimates that illegal operators account for more than 62% of gambling activity nationwide